Updated October 2026: This article has been rewritten and expanded with current information.

When this post first ran at the end of 2013, Canada's Anti-Spam Legislation, usually shortened to CASL, was still months away from taking effect. Marketers were nervous. The law was described as one of the toughest anti-spam regimes in the world, and it reached well beyond Canadian companies. More than a decade later, CASL is part of everyday email marketing in Canada, and its main rules have barely changed.
This guide explains what CASL covers, the three things every commercial message needs, how consent works, what the law does not cover, and what enforcement has looked like so far. It is written for anyone who sends promotional email or texts to people in Canada. It is a plain-language overview, not legal advice.
What CASL is
CASL grew out of a federal Anti-Spam Action Plan launched in 2004. A task force reported in 2005 and recommended a dedicated law. Parliament passed one, and it received royal assent on December 15, 2010. The rules on commercial messages took effect on July 1, 2014.
The law also bans installing software on someone's computer in the course of commercial activity without express consent, and redirecting messages by altering transmission data. This guide focuses on the messaging rules, where most organizations meet the law.
Three federal bodies enforce it. The Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission (CRTC) is the main enforcer. The Competition Bureau handles misleading content, and the Office of the Privacy Commissioner deals with address harvesting and related privacy problems.
- 2004 to 2005
Ottawa launches an Anti-Spam Action Plan. Its task force reports in May 2005 and recommends a dedicated anti-spam law. - December 15, 2010
The legislation receives royal assent. - July 1, 2014
The main rules on commercial electronic messages take effect. - June 2017
An order in council postpones the private right of action, which had been due July 1, 2017. It remains not in force. - July 1, 2017
The 36-month transition for consent implied from pre-2014 relationships ends. - May 1, 2018
The CRTC announces its first CASL undertaking over text messages: $100,000 from ticket reseller 514-BILLETS. - June 5, 2020
The Federal Court of Appeal rules CASL constitutional in the CompuFinder case. - March 4, 2021
The Supreme Court of Canada declines to hear CompuFinder's appeal, leaving that ruling in place.
What counts as a commercial electronic message
CASL applies to a "commercial electronic message," or CEM. That means an electronic message where one purpose is to encourage the recipient to take part in a commercial activity. Email, texts, instant messages and social media direct messages can all qualify. An otherwise ordinary email can become a CEM if it promotes an offer, and guidance from Conestoga College notes that even a promotional link in an email signature may be enough.
Geography matters less than many people expect. CASL applies to messages sent from or accessed by a computer system in Canada. A U.S. or European business with Canadian subscribers is covered even if it has no office in Canada.
The three requirements for every message
Every CEM must meet three tests.
- Consent. You need the recipient's express or implied consent before you send. You also carry the burden of proving it, so keep records of when and how each person signed up.
- Identification. The message must identify who sent it and on whose behalf. It must include a mailing address plus at least one of a phone number, an email address or a web address. A clear link to a page with this information is acceptable, and the contact details must stay valid for at least 60 days after sending.
- Unsubscribe. There must be a free, easy way to opt out, using the same channel where practicable, or a link to a web page. The Act requires the request to be honoured within 10 business days, with no further action needed from the person.
How consent works
Express consent is the gold standard because it does not expire. To get it, you must explain why you are asking, say who is asking, and tell people they can withdraw at any time. The request must be separate from general terms and conditions, and pre-checked boxes do not count. A common mistake is emailing people to ask whether you may email them. That request is itself a CEM, so you need consent to send it.
Implied consent comes from an existing relationship, and most kinds have a clock attached.
| Basis for sending | How it arises | How long it lasts |
|---|---|---|
| Express consent | The person actively opts in (no pre-checked boxes) after being told the purpose, who is asking, and that they can withdraw. | Until they unsubscribe |
| Implied: purchase or contract | The person bought, leased or contracted for something from you. | Two years from the transaction |
| Implied: inquiry or application | The person asked about or applied for your product or service. | Six months from the inquiry |
| Implied: non-business relationship | A donation or gift to, volunteer work for, or membership in a registered charity, political party or organization, candidate, club or association. | Two years |
| Implied: published or shared address | The address was conspicuously published or handed to you, without a "no messages" statement, and your message relates to the person's business role. | While those conditions hold |
Simplified from the Act (S.C. 2010, c. 23) and official guidance. It is not legal advice.
When CASL started in 2014, consent was also implied for 36 months for relationships that already involved messaging. That transition ended on July 1, 2017, so older lists built before 2014 now need a current basis like any other.
Some messages need consent but must still carry identification and unsubscribe details. They include quotes someone asked for, messages that complete an agreed transaction, warranty, recall and safety notices, and factual updates about an existing account or subscription.
What CASL does not cover
Several kinds of message fall outside the law entirely. They include messages between family members or people with a personal relationship, messages the recipient asked for, many messages within or between organizations that already have a relationship, and messages required by law. Fundraising messages from registered charities and political parties or candidates are also exempt when that is their primary purpose.
Voice is the other big gap. The Act says its message rules do not apply to live two-way voice calls, faxes to a telephone account, or recorded voice messages sent to a telephone account. Telemarketing calls fall under the CRTC's separate telemarketing rules and the National Do Not Call List.
A test case: political texts in Ontario, 2018
Those boundaries came up during the June 2018 Ontario provincial election. Many voters reported unexpected texts and calls from Ontario Proud, a conservative third-party advocacy group, and asked how it had got their numbers. The Globe and Mail reported that the group used outside vendors that worked from the Canadian Numbering Plan, the public system that assigns blocks of numbers to carriers.
Founder Jeff Ballingall argued the group was not breaking any laws because it was not selling anything. The CRTC did not comment. No regulator ruled on the texts in the coverage we found. The episode shows the key point: CASL turns on whether a message is commercial, so many political messages sit in a grey zone that CASL was not designed to settle.
Penalties and enforcement
The maximum administrative penalty is $1 million per violation for an individual and $10 million for an organization. Directors and officers can be held liable for violations they authorized or took part in. In practice, penalties so far have been far lower, and many cases end with a negotiated undertaking: a payment plus a promise to set up a compliance program.
| Year | Organization | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| 2015 to 2017 | CompuFinder (training company) | Notice of violation for $1.1 million, reduced to $200,000 on CRTC review. The courts later upheld the law itself. |
| 2018 | 514-BILLETS (ticket resale) | $100,000 undertaking over texts sent without consent or sender identification, 2014 to 2016. |
| 2020 | OneClass (education platform) | $100,000 undertaking over unconsented messages and a Chrome extension installed on students' computers. |
| 2021 | An individual sender | $75,000 penalty, which the CRTC called its largest against an individual under CASL to that point. |
Selected public enforcement actions reported by the CRTC and law-firm reviews.
The CompuFinder case matters most. The company argued that the whole law was unconstitutional. On June 5, 2020, the Federal Court of Appeal disagreed. It found CASL fell within Parliament's trade and commerce power and that its limits on commercial expression were justified. It also held that scraping addresses from directories does not create implied consent, and that a broken second unsubscribe link next to a working one fails the law's test. The Supreme Court of Canada declined to hear the case on March 4, 2021.
The private right of action
CASL was designed to let individuals sue senders for violations, starting July 1, 2017. In June 2017, after business groups complained that parts of the law were ambiguous, the government postponed those sections indefinitely, pending a parliamentary review. They have not been brought into force since. For now, the risk is regulatory enforcement rather than class actions under CASL itself.
How CASL differs from the U.S. CAN-SPAM Act
The biggest difference is the starting point. The U.S. CAN-SPAM Act is broadly an opt-out law: you may email people until they unsubscribe, as long as you follow its rules on honest headers, identification and opt-out. CASL is opt-in: you need express or implied consent before the first message. CASL also puts the burden of proving consent on the sender, so a list that is fine under U.S. rules may not be fine for Canadian recipients.
A practical checklist for senders
- Audit your list. Tag each Canadian contact with the basis for messaging them: express consent, or implied consent with the date it started.
- Use unchecked opt-in boxes with a short statement of purpose, your organization's name and contact details, and a line saying people can withdraw consent.
- Keep proof of when, where and how each person agreed.
- Track expiry dates. Set reminders for six-month inquiry and two-year purchase windows, and ask for express consent before they run out.
- Check every template for a mailing address, a second contact method, and one working, prominent unsubscribe link.
- Process opt-outs fast, well inside 10 business days, and sync them across every tool that sends mail or texts.
- Do not buy or scrape lists. Harvested addresses do not carry implied consent.
If you receive spam yourself, the federal Spam Reporting Centre at fightspam.gc.ca accepts reports, which the CRTC and its partners use in investigations.
Sources
- Justice Laws Website: S.C. 2010, c. 23 (CASL full text)
- CRTC: CASL Act, regulations and guidelines
- Canada Gazette: Order postponing the private right of action (2017)
- Conestoga College: Canada's Anti-Spam Legislation guide
- CRTC: 514-BILLETS to pay $100,000 (2018)
- CRTC: CASL enforcement summary, October 2020 to March 2021
- BLG: Federal Court of Appeal rules CASL constitutionally valid (2020)
- BLG: Canada's anti-spam legislation, 2020 year in review
- MLT Aikins: Supreme Court of Canada confirms CASL is constitutional
- The Globe and Mail: Who is Ontario Proud and why is it texting you? (2018)
Top image: "Generic-valuta-sign" by Nezzo at Danish Wikipedia, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons (resized). Charts by Thank You Robot.
0 Comments