Unpacking the Privacy Concerns Surrounding Meta's New Twitter Challenger, Threads

Updated October 2026: This post has been expanded from its original July 2023 version with the European regulatory background, what changed about Threads' privacy and account controls after launch, its growth and fediverse integration, and privacy steps that still apply. It is a historical account; details describe the time it covers, not today.

Smartphone screen showing a grid of app icons

Meta launched Threads on July 5, 2023, as a text-first rival to Twitter, which Elon Musk had bought the previous autumn. Because anyone with an Instagram account could sign up in a couple of taps and bring their followers with them, growth was immediate: about 30 million sign-ups in the first day, and roughly 100 million within five days, a pace Mark Zuckerberg announced on July 10.

The launch also drew close attention to how much data the new app collected, why it was not available in the European Union, and what Meta meant when it promised that Threads would one day connect to open social networks such as Mastodon. This post looks at those privacy questions as they stood in July 2023, and then at what actually happened over the following three years.

What the App Store label showed

Apple requires every app to publish a privacy "nutrition label" describing the kinds of data it collects. Threads' label, which Meta writes itself, listed a very long range of data types, and the security company Kaspersky noted at the time that it was identical to Instagram's. That made sense technically, since Threads was built on Instagram's account system, but it meant a text-posting app disclosed the same broad collection as one of the most data-hungry apps on the market.

Kaspersky also pointed out that these labels are self-reported and not always precise; Threads listed location data, for example, even though the app did not ask for location permission at the time. Other critics, including a widely shared TIME article, argued that Threads collected far more information than a microblogging service needs. Privacy-minded users contrasted it with smaller, newer networks such as Bluesky and Mastodon, which were built around different business models.

Why Threads skipped the European Union

Threads launched in about 100 countries, including the United Kingdom, but not in the EU. Meta did not give a single official reason, and the timing pointed to a regulatory environment that had just become more difficult for it.

A record GDPR fine

On May 22, 2023, Ireland's Data Protection Commission fined Meta Ireland €1.2 billion, the largest penalty yet under the EU's General Data Protection Regulation. The regulator found that Meta's transfers of European users' personal data to the United States did not meet the requirements set by the EU's top court in its 2020 Schrems II ruling, and ordered Meta to suspend those transfers.

A court ruling on targeted ads

On July 4, 2023, the day before Threads launched, the Court of Justice of the European Union ruled in a case between Meta and Germany's competition authority, the Bundeskartellamt. The court said Meta could not rely on its "legitimate interest" to process users' data for personalized advertising, a legal basis Meta had recently switched to. Instead, profiling that combined data from Facebook, Instagram, WhatsApp and third-party websites would need users' real consent. The ruling also confirmed that competition regulators can consider GDPR compliance when judging whether a dominant company is abusing its position. Privacy activist Max Schrems called it a huge blow for Meta.

The Digital Markets Act

The EU's Digital Markets Act was also coming into force for the largest "gatekeeper" platforms, with rules on combining personal data across services. Reporting around the eventual EU launch tied the delay to these DMA obligations as much as to the GDPR.

The ActivityPub promise

Meta said at launch that Threads would eventually support ActivityPub, an open protocol published by the World Wide Web Consortium and used by Mastodon and other services in what is known as the fediverse. In principle, that would let people follow Threads accounts from other apps, and could one day let users leave Threads without losing their audience.

Reaction among fediverse users was split. Some saw Meta's interest as validation of open, decentralized social media. Others worried that a company with hundreds of millions of users would overwhelm smaller communities, and some server administrators signed a pledge, nicknamed the "Fedipact," to block Threads from their servers entirely.

What happened next

Engagement fell, then growth resumed

The early rush did not last. Daily active users fell sharply over July 2023, and average time spent per user dropped from about 20 minutes on launch day to under 3 minutes by August 1, according to third-party measurements. Zuckerberg called the drop normal. Growth then resumed steadily, as the chart shows.

Threads monthly active users, as reported by Meta
October 2023
100 M
February 2024
130 M
November 2024
275 M
April 2025
350 M
August 2025
400 M
Sources: TechCrunch (February 2024, August 2025); Wikipedia summary of Meta announcements. Millions; the October 2023 figure was reported as "north of" 100 million.

By August 2025, Instagram head Adam Mosseri said Threads had passed 400 million monthly users. Similarweb estimated in June 2025 that Threads had about 115 million daily mobile users, close to X's 132 million, though X remained far larger on the web.

Account deletion was fixed

At launch, the only way to delete a Threads profile was to delete the linked Instagram account as well. Meta's chief privacy officer for product said in September 2023 that separating the two had been extremely challenging, and promised a fix by December. In November 2023 Meta added a "Delete or Deactivate Profile" option in Threads' account settings that removes the Threads profile without touching Instagram.

The EU launch

Threads finally opened in the EU on December 14, 2023, about five months after the rest of the world. The European version added a mode for browsing without a profile, which did not require logging in with Instagram, though users in that mode could only read a single algorithmic feed and search for accounts.

Fediverse integration arrived slowly

Threads and the fediverse
  1. July 2023
    Meta promises future ActivityPub support at launch
  2. December 2023
    Zuckerberg announces a test of showing some Threads posts on the fediverse
  3. March 2024
    Beta lets public profiles opt in to fediverse sharing
  4. June 2024
    Fediverse sharing expands to all eligible users outside the EU
  5. December 2024
    Threads users can follow fediverse accounts, and vice versa
  6. June 2025
    A separate fediverse feed and fediverse profile search arrive
Sources: TechCrunch (June 2025), NBC News, Wikipedia summary of Meta announcements.

Fediverse sharing remains opt-in, and the integration still has limits. In June 2025, for example, fediverse posts appeared in their own feed, and only top-level posts were shown there. A full "take your followers and leave" option, which privacy advocates hoped for, has not arrived.

Ads and direct messages

Zuckerberg had said Threads would not focus on making money until it reached hundreds of millions of users. By early 2026 Meta had begun rolling out ads on the service. When Threads added direct messages, they launched without end-to-end encryption, which drew criticism given that WhatsApp, another Meta app, encrypts by default.

How to limit what Threads knows about you

If you use Threads today, these steps reduce the data you expose. All are free and built in:

  • Review the privacy label yourself. On iPhone, open Threads' App Store page and scroll to App Privacy. On Android, check the Data safety section in Google Play. Both list what the developer says it collects.
  • Limit phone permissions. In your phone's settings, turn off access to contacts, location and photos unless you actually need them. On iPhone, choose "Ask App Not to Track" when prompted.
  • Use a private profile if you want. A private profile limits who can see your posts and replies.
  • Think before opting in to fediverse sharing. Once posts are shared to other servers, copies can be stored there, outside Meta's control.
  • Check ad settings in Meta's Accounts Center. Threads shares the same account system as Instagram, so the ad preferences there apply.
  • Know how to leave. In Threads, go to Settings, then Account, then Delete or Deactivate Profile. Deactivation hides your profile; deletion removes it without deleting Instagram.

The privacy worries raised in July 2023 were largely about structure: Threads was a new app riding on an old account system and an advertising business. Three years later that structure is unchanged, but users have more control than they did at launch, and the open-protocol promise, while incomplete, has partly been kept.

Sources

Top image: "Librem 5 - AppLauncher (cropped)" by Purism, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons (resized). Charts by Thank You Robot.

Post a Comment

0 Comments