Updated October 2026: This post has been expanded from its original February 2024 version and retitled to make clear that the toothbrush botnet was never confirmed. It now explains how the story spread and was corrected, and covers the real IoT botnets, such as Mirai, that made it sound believable. It is a historical account; details describe the time it covers, not today.

In early February 2024, a story spread across technology news sites and social media that about 3 million internet-connected toothbrushes had been infected with malware and used to knock a Swiss company's website offline. It had everything a viral security story needs: an everyday object, a huge number, a hidden threat in the bathroom, and a hint of state-backed hackers.
It was not true. Within days, the security company quoted in the original report said the toothbrush example had been a hypothetical illustration, not a real incident it had investigated. This post explains how a scenario became a news story, why security researchers doubted it from the start, and what real attacks on connected devices actually look like.
How the story started
The claim first appeared at the turn of January and February 2024 in an article about cybercrime by the Swiss German-language newspaper Aargauer Zeitung, part of the CH Media group, under the headline "The toothbrushes are attacking." It said some 3 million electric toothbrushes programmed with Java had been quietly infected with malware and used in a distributed denial-of-service (DDoS) attack, in which a flood of junk traffic from many devices overwhelms a target. The attack had supposedly taken a Swiss company's website down for four hours and caused damage in the millions.
The article attributed its information to Stefan Züger of the Swiss branch of Fortinet, a large network security vendor, who made the broader point that any device connected to the internet can be pulled into an attack.
How it spread
Swiss and German outlets relayed the report, then English-language technology sites such as Tom's Hardware picked it up and translated its claims, and from there it moved quickly through aggregators and social media. Each retelling tended to drop the qualifiers. A scene used to illustrate a risk became a reported attack, and the reported attack gained a specific victim, a specific count and a specific programming language.
The pattern is common with security news. Original reporting in one language is summarized in another; secondary outlets cite each other rather than the source; and a vivid detail, such as Java on a toothbrush, makes the claim feel concrete enough to trust.
Why researchers doubted it
Experienced security researchers, including Kevin Beaumont and Robert Graham, were skeptical almost immediately. Beaumont called it "simply a made up example." Their objections were practical:
- No evidence was published. There was no named victim, no traffic data, no malware sample and no technical indicators, the material that normally accompanies a real botnet report.
- The scale did not fit. Three million compromised units of a single type of toothbrush would be an enormous botnet, far larger than many real ones, and would almost certainly have been noticed by other researchers and network operators.
- Toothbrushes are not usually on the internet. Connected toothbrushes typically send brushing data to a phone app over Bluetooth. A device that only talks to a nearby phone cannot easily be reached, infected and directed from across the internet.
- Attackers have better targets. Routers, cameras and video recorders are always on, directly reachable and often poorly secured, which is why real IoT botnets use them.
The correction
On February 7, 2024, Fortinet issued a statement, reported by BleepingComputer, clarifying that the toothbrush example had been "presented during an interview as an illustration of a given type of attack, and it is not based on research from Fortinet or FortiGuard Labs." The company said that "due to translations the narrative on this topic has been stretched to the point where hypothetical and actual scenarios are blurred," and FortiGuard Labs said it had not seen IoT botnets targeting toothbrushes or similar devices.
The Aargauer Zeitung disputed the translation explanation. It said Fortinet's Swiss representatives had presented the case as a real attack, including how long the website was down, and that the passage was sent to Fortinet for review before publication without objection. Whichever side's account is right, no evidence of a real toothbrush botnet was ever published. Several outlets that had run the claim, including Tom's Hardware, added updates or published follow-ups, but the original version kept circulating on social media.
Real IoT botnets are serious enough
Part of why the toothbrush story was believable is that connected-device botnets are a genuine and well-documented problem. The best-known example is Mirai.
Mirai
Mirai is malware for Linux-based devices that was first identified in August 2016 by the research group MalwareMustDie. It scanned the internet for devices such as IP cameras and home routers with Telnet open, then tried a built-in list of more than 60 common factory-default usernames and passwords. Rebooting an infected device removed the malware, but it would typically be reinfected within minutes unless the password was changed.
In the autumn of 2016 Mirai was behind some of the largest DDoS attacks seen up to that time:
On October 21, 2016, Mirai-powered attacks on Dyn, a company that provided DNS services for major websites, made sites including GitHub, Netflix and Airbnb unreachable for many users. In late November 2016, a Mirai variant's failed attempt to exploit routers caused about 900,000 Deutsche Telekom customers' routers to crash.
Mirai's author, using the name Anna-senpai, released the source code on a hacking forum, which allowed others to build variants. In December 2017, Paras Jha, Josiah White and Dalton Norman pleaded guilty in U.S. federal court in connection with Mirai. They were sentenced to probation and community service and assisted with other cybersecurity investigations. Jha was separately ordered in 2018 to pay $8.6 million in restitution for attacks on Rutgers University.
The botnets that followed
Mirai's code became a template. Variants such as Satori, Okiru and Masuta followed in 2017 and 2018, each adding new exploits for routers and other devices. More recently, a botnet called Aisuru, first spotted in August 2024, has been linked to record-setting attacks, including one of 31.4 terabits per second against Cloudflare. In other words, real IoT botnets have grown far larger in attack power than anything the toothbrush story described, using ordinary network gear rather than bathroom gadgets.
How to judge the next viral security story
- Look for evidence, not anecdotes. Real incident reports include technical details: malware names, affected device models, traffic data or indicators of compromise.
- Find the original source. If every article cites another article, trace it back. Check whether the original described an event or an example.
- Watch for translation drift. Claims that cross languages through summaries can lose the words that signal a hypothetical.
- Check whether researchers agree. When independent security researchers publicly question a claim, wait before sharing it.
How to keep your own devices out of a botnet
The real risk sits in the devices that Mirai and its successors target. These free steps cover most of it:
- Change default passwords. This is the single step that would have stopped the original Mirai. Use a unique password for your router's admin page and for every camera or recorder.
- Update firmware. Turn on automatic updates where available, and check the maker's support page for older devices.
- Replace devices that no longer get updates. End-of-life routers and cameras are a favorite target because their flaws are never fixed.
- Turn off remote access you do not use. Disable features such as remote administration, Telnet and UPnP port forwarding unless you need them.
- Separate smart devices. Many routers offer a guest network. Putting cameras, plugs and speakers on it limits what an infected device can reach.
The toothbrush botnet never existed, but the attention it got was not entirely wasted if it led people to check the router in the hallway. That is where the real fight over connected devices is taking place.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Mirai (malware)
- Wikipedia: Botnet
- Wikipedia: Electric toothbrush
- BleepingComputer: No, 3 million electric toothbrushes were not used in a DDoS attack (Feb. 7, 2024, updated Feb. 8)
- Tom's Hardware: Security firm now says toothbrush DDoS attack didn't happen, but source publication says company presented it as real (Feb. 2024)
- Netzwoche: Update: Zahnbürsten haben doch keine DDoS-Angriffe ausgeführt (Feb. 9, 2024, in German)
- Security Boulevard: 'Total bollocks' — no, your toothbrush isn't DDoS'ing (Feb. 2024)
- BleepingComputer: IoT security news
Top image: "Teddy bear that says remote-controlled (via smartphone app) sentences" by Syced, CC0 1.0, via Wikimedia Commons (resized). Charts by Thank You Robot.
0 Comments