Emergency Alert for Incident at Pickering Nuclear Power Plant 'Sent in Error'

Updated October 2026: This post has been expanded from its original January 2020 version with a full timeline of the false Pickering nuclear alert, what the official investigation found, how it compares with Hawaii's 2018 missile alert, and what has changed at the plant since. It is a historical account; details describe the time it covers, not today.

Pickering Nuclear Generating Station seen from the Lake Ontario shore

Early on the morning of Sunday, January 12, 2020, phones, televisions and radios across Ontario lit up with an emergency alert about an "incident" at the Pickering Nuclear Generating Station, east of Toronto. The message said there had been no abnormal release of radioactivity and that people near the plant did not need to take protective action. It did not say what the incident was.

There was no incident. The alert had been sent by mistake during a routine test. It took about 40 minutes for the plant's operator to say so publicly and nearly two hours for a correcting alert to reach phones. This post looks back at what happened, why it took so long to fix, and what the episode taught emergency managers about public alert systems.

The plant and the alert

Pickering sits on the north shore of Lake Ontario in the city of Pickering, in the Durham Region. (An earlier version of this post placed it on Lake Huron, which was wrong.) It is owned by Ontario Power Generation (OPG) and has eight CANDU reactors, two of which had been shut down and defuelled since the early 2000s. In 2020 the station sat within a short drive of millions of people in the Greater Toronto Area.

The alert went out at 7:24 a.m. Eastern time through Alert Ready, Canada's national public alerting system. Alert Ready had carried emergency warnings on broadcast television and radio since March 2015, and Canadian wireless carriers had been required to relay alerts to compatible phones since April 2018. Because the message was issued province-wide, it reached people hundreds of kilometres from Pickering, not just those living near the plant.

The wording created confusion. It described an incident and spoke of emergency staff responding, but it also said there was no release of radioactivity and no action was needed "at this time." People were told to keep monitoring local news. Journalists, though, had nothing more to report, and Durham Regional Police said publicly that they too had received the alert and were seeking clarification from local emergency managers.

How the morning unfolded

The Pickering false alert, January 12, 2020
  1. 7:24 a.m.
    Alert Ready message about an "incident" at Pickering is sent across Ontario.
  2. About 8:04 a.m.
    OPG posts on Twitter that the alert was sent in error and there is no danger to the public or the environment.
  3. 8:23 a.m.
    The premier's office confirms the Provincial Emergency Operations Centre sent the alert by mistake.
  4. About 9:12 a.m.
    A second emergency alert says there is no active nuclear situation and the first message was an error.
  5. January 12-13
    More than 32,000 orders for potassium iodide pills are placed through OPG's preparedness website.
  6. February 27, 2020
    The province releases the findings of its investigation into the error.
Sources: CBC News (January 12 and 14, 2020); Wikipedia, "Alert Ready" and "Pickering Nuclear Generating Station".

Solicitor General Sylvia Jones said that day that the alert had been triggered during a routine training exercise at the province's emergency operations centre. She explained that it appeared someone had sent a test through a "live" pathway instead of the test pathway during system checks that were carried out twice a day. OPG's chief nuclear officer said the plant was operating normally and that OPG had its own notification process it would follow in a real emergency.

Criticism came quickly. Pickering's mayor and Toronto's mayor both called for a full investigation, and opposition politicians argued that public confidence in alerts depended on their accuracy. Many people who received the message said they had spent the morning unsure whether to pack up their families or stay put.

What the investigation found

The province published the results of its investigation on February 27, 2020. It concluded that the alert was caused by human error. A duty officer at the Provincial Emergency Operations Centre, starting his shift, had performed a regular internal test. It was common practice to log in to the live system first, to confirm it was working, before switching to a separate test version. In this case, he was still logged in to the live system when he sent the test message.

The officer realized what had happened. The delay in correcting it came from what followed. According to reporting on the investigation, he could not get clear direction from Emergency Management Ontario supervisors on how to send a follow-up alert that would interrupt broadcasts and phones the same way, or on whether a second alert should be sent at all. That uncertainty is why OPG's social media post arrived well before an official correction.

The Hawaii comparison

The Pickering alert came one day before the second anniversary of a far more frightening mistake. On January 13, 2018, at 8:08 a.m. local time, the Hawaii Emergency Management Agency sent a ballistic missile warning to phones across the state, ending with the words "This is not a drill." A correcting alert followed 38 minutes later.

The two cases had a lot in common. Both happened around a shift change. Both involved a drill or test being treated as real. And in both, the system made it easy to send a live alert and harder to send a correction. After Hawaii, the state required two people to sign off on alerts, added a fast cancellation option, and the U.S. Federal Communications Commission later adopted rules on reporting false alerts. Pickering showed that similar weaknesses could exist in a different country with different software.

Hawaii, 2018Ontario (Pickering), 2020
Alert sentJan 13, 8:08 a.m. HSTJan 12, 7:24 a.m. ET
ContentIncoming ballistic missileUnspecified nuclear plant incident
CauseDrill treated as real during shift changeTest sent while logged in to live system
Time to official correcting alertAbout 38 minutesAbout 1 hour 48 minutes

Sources: Wikipedia, "2018 Hawaii false missile alert"; CBC News; Wikipedia, "Alert Ready".

What happened next

The false alarm had a side effect that preparedness officials welcomed. Potassium iodide pills, which help protect the thyroid gland from radioactive iodine in a nuclear emergency, are delivered automatically to homes and businesses within 10 kilometres of Ontario's nuclear plants, and people living 10 to 50 kilometres away can order them free. OPG normally received 100 to 200 orders a month. In the day and a half after the alert, CBC News reported more than 32,000 orders, mostly from the Greater Toronto Area.

Canada's alert system continued to face scrutiny. In April 2020, Nova Scotia's RCMP was criticized for not using Alert Ready to warn residents during a mass shooting. Other provinces have had their own errors since, including a test alert accidentally reissued in British Columbia in 2021, a test sent nine times in Alberta in 2023, and a local boil-water advisory in Saskatchewan that went province-wide in November 2023 because of a software preset.

The plant itself has changed. Ontario extended Pickering's operating life beyond its earlier planned closure. Units 1 and 4 were removed from service in October and December 2024, ending operations at the older Pickering A reactors. In January 2024, the province announced support for refurbishing the four Pickering B units, work expected to run into the mid-2030s and keep them running for decades.

What this means for you

Emergency alerts are designed to reach people fast, and occasional errors are a cost of that speed. A few habits help when an alarming message arrives:

  • Don't ignore it, but verify. Check the official accounts of the agency named in the alert, local police, or the facility operator. In the Pickering case, OPG's own post was the first reliable correction.
  • Read the instructions carefully. The Pickering message actually said no action was needed. Alerts that require you to shelter or evacuate will say so.
  • Know your local risks ahead of time. If you live near a nuclear plant in Ontario, check whether you are in the zone that can order free potassium iodide pills, and keep them with your emergency kit.
  • Keep alerts turned on. In Canada, the most urgent wireless alerts cannot be switched off, and in other places turning alerts off means missing real warnings. A rare false alarm is not a good reason to opt out.
  • Have a backup source. A battery radio or a trusted local news station can confirm or correct what arrives on your phone.

For agencies, the lessons from Pickering and Hawaii are now standard advice: separate test and live systems clearly, require a second person before a live alert goes out, and prepare correction messages in advance so a mistake can be fixed in minutes rather than hours.

Sources

Top image: "Pickering Nuclear Generating Station at Beachfront Park, June 6 2026 (03)" by Dillan Payne, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons (resized). Charts by Thank You Robot.

Post a Comment

0 Comments